Jesus’ Discipleship and the Failure of the Disciples in the Gospel of Mark according to Dietrich Bonhoeffer

Figure Ilustration AI

FORMOSA NEWS - Jakarta Barat - Failure Shapes Faith: Study Reframes Christian Discipleship through Gospel of Mark.  A 2026 study by Emilia Kartika, Hiu Willison, David Sulardi Sastro, and Yosef Antonius from Bethel The Way Theological College reveals that failure plays a central role in Christian discipleship. Published in the Asian Journal of Philosophy and Religion, the research analyzes the Gospel of Mark alongside the theology of Dietrich Bonhoeffer. The findings matter because they challenge modern church practices that prioritize measurable success over spiritual formation. The study shows that in the Gospel of Mark, the disciples of Jesus are consistently portrayed as misunderstanding, fearful, and often failing. Yet, instead of being rejected, they are continually guided and shaped by Jesus. This reframing positions failure not as a weakness to eliminate, but as a necessary part of spiritual growth.

Rethinking Discipleship in a Results-Driven Era
In many contemporary churches, discipleship is often defined by structured programs, doctrinal teaching, and measurable outcomes such as attendance or course completion. While these approaches aim to build knowledge, they can overlook deeper relational and spiritual development. This issue is increasingly relevant as religious communities worldwide grapple with disengagement and superficial participation. Many believers receive theological instruction but do not actively participate in mentoring or forming others. The study highlights this gap and points to the need for a more relational and process-oriented model. The Gospel of Mark offers a contrasting narrative. Rather than presenting ideal followers, it depicts disciples who struggle repeatedly failing to understand Jesus’ teachings, acting out of fear, and even abandoning Him at critical moments. Despite this, Jesus continues to walk with them.

Simple Method, Deep Analysis
The research uses a qualitative library-based approach. The authors focus exclusively on the Gospel of Mark, analyzing key passages that describe the relationship between Jesus and His disciples. They apply narrative and thematic reading methods to understand how failure functions within the story. To deepen the interpretation, the study incorporates the theology of Dietrich Bonhoeffer, particularly his concept of Nachfolge, or “following Christ.” Bonhoeffer’s work emphasizes lived obedience and relational commitment rather than intellectual agreement alone. The researchers rely on biblical texts, theological writings, and contemporary scholarship to build a comprehensive framework. No fieldwork or surveys were conducted; all findings emerge from textual and theological analysis.

Key Findings: Failure Is Not the End
The study presents several clear findings that reshape how discipleship is understood:

• Discipleship begins with relationship. Jesus calls His followers “to be with Him,” making companionship the foundation of formation.
• Failure is consistent and visible. The disciples repeatedly misunderstand teachings, fear danger, seek status, and deny Jesus.
• Growth is non-linear. Spiritual development unfolds gradually, often through confusion and correction.
• Jesus remains faithful. Despite repeated failure, Jesus does not abandon His disciples but continues guiding them.
• Failure becomes formative. Instead of disrupting discipleship, failure becomes the context in which transformation occurs.

These findings suggest that the Gospel of Mark intentionally highlights weakness to shift focus away from human performance and toward Jesus’ faithfulness.

Real-World Impact: Changing How Churches Teach and Lead
The implications of this research extend beyond theology into practical church life and leadership. The study offers several actionable insights:

• Shift from programs to relationships. Churches should prioritize mentoring, companionship, and shared life over rigid curricula.
• Normalize failure as part of growth. Instead of excluding individuals who struggle, communities should create safe spaces for learning through mistakes.
• Focus on multiplication, not just participation. Discipleship should produce individuals who can guide others, not just passive learners.
• Strengthen community-based formation. Spiritual growth happens within relationships, not in isolation or purely instructional settings.
• Redefine leadership roles. Leaders should act as mentors and companions, not just teachers or program managers.

These changes could influence how religious institutions design education programs, train leaders, and measure success. The findings also resonate with broader discussions in education and leadership about the value of experiential learning and resilience.

Author Profiles

Emilia Kartika, M.Th. – Lecturer in Biblical Theology at Sekolah Tinggi Teologi Bethel The Way, specializing in Gospel studies and discipleship.

Hiu Willison, M.Th. – Scholar in Practical Theology focusing on spiritual formation and church practice.

David Sulardi Sastro, M.Th. – Researcher in Systematic Theology and Christian ethics.

Yosef Antonius, M.Th. – Lecturer in Pastoral Theology and church leadership.

Sources

Emilia Kartika, Hiu Willison, David Sulardi Sastro, Yosef Antonius (2026). “Jesus’ Discipleship and the Failure of the Disciples in the Gospel of Mark according to Dietrich Bonhoeffer”, Asian Journal of Philosophy and Religion, Vol. 5 No. 1, 2026. Hal 1-12.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.55927/ajpr.v5i1.16390
URL: https://journal.formosapublisher.org/index.php/ajpr