In
September 2026, researchers Anggi Dwi Astuti, I Wayan Mudra, I Made Pande
Artadi, and Nyoman Dewi Pebriyani from Universitas Mercu Buana published a
detailed architectural study evaluating how the interior design of the
Al-Jabbar Grand Mosque in Bandung, West Java, intuitively influences user
behavior. Published in Jurnal Multidisplin Madani (MUDIMA), the study
investigates how monumental places of worship act as both sacred spaces for
prayer and public hubs for tourism and social gathering. By assessing the
spatial configuration, lighting, scale, and materials of the interior, the
researchers identified key design mechanisms that guide worshippers and
visitors without the need for spoken or written directions.
Navigating Sacred and Public Demands in Modern Mosques
Monumental
mosques across Indonesia increasingly function as double-purpose institutions.
While their primary role is providing a sacred space for Islamic rituals, they
simultaneously serve as urban landmarks, educational complexes, and religious
tourism destinations. This dual identity often creates spatial overlap between
individuals seeking quiet spiritual devotion and tourists capturing photos or
exploring architectural features.
To
evaluate this dynamic, the research team applied "affordance
theory"—a concept developed by psychologist James J. Gibson suggesting
that physical environments inherently suggest or "invite" specific
human actions. The study categorized interior spatial cues into three distinct
dimensions:
- Sacred Affordance: Spatial features like high domes, directed natural
light, and the qibla alignment that cultivate spiritual focus,
tranquility, and devotion.
- Functional Affordance: Physical elements such as floor elevation changes,
tactile carpet patterns, and accessible ramps that facilitate movement,
order, and hygiene.
- Social Affordance: Open plazas, transition hallways, and wide corridors
that encourage community gatherings, discussions, and visual
documentation.
Research Methodology
The
research team employed an interpretive qualitative single-case study design
focused on the main prayer spaces, transition corridors, wudu areas, and public
zones of the Al-Jabbar Grand Mosque.
- Behavioral Mapping: Field observations were conducted across 6 to 8
sessions lasting 30 to 60 minutes each, capturing user behaviors during
both active prayer times and non-prayer hours.
- User Interviews: Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 34
purposively selected individuals across three user categories: 10 active
local worshippers, 18 tourists/visitors, and 6 mosque management staff
members.
- Data Analysis: Observational floor plans, visual documentation, field
notes, and interview transcripts were systematically coded and
cross-triangulated to map physical features against user perceptions and
movement patterns.
Key Findings and "Affordance Conflicts"
The
empirical data revealed that specific physical elements inside the Al-Jabbar
Grand Mosque directly prompt intuitive user behaviors without explicit signage.
However, the same visual landmarks that inspire religious reverence frequently
attract non-ritual tourism, leading to spatial friction.
- Intuitive Prayer Alignment: The main prayer hall's wide-span, pillarless
construction gives worshippers an unobstructed view of the golden
triangle-shaped mihrab. Striped carpet patterns (saf) provide
explicit geometric cues that lead congregants to line up automatically for
prayer without verbal instructions.
- Tactile Boundaries and
Inclusive Access: Floor
height differences (5 to 15 cm) and changes in flooring material (from
rough outdoor tiles to polished marble or carpet) signal clean, sacred
boundaries where footwear must be removed. Additionally, sloped ramps
alongside main staircases provide clear accessibility cues for wheelchair
users and elderly visitors.
- Natural Lighting and Spiritual
Focus: Geometric glass openings in
the dome allow dynamic sunlight to create a high-contrast visual gradient
toward the mihrab and the central "Allah" ceiling calligraphy,
directing visual attention upward and forward.
- Identification of Affordance
Conflicts: The study revealed that
monumental elements—such as the central dome crown and the golden
mihrab—trigger competing behaviors. During non-prayer times and weekend
tourist surges, visitors frequently cross prayer lines (saf) or
crowd the mihrab hallway for group photography, disrupting the quiet
environment required by active worshippers.
Real-World Impact and Architectural Design Guidelines
To
resolve spatial conflicts in dual-purpose religious monuments, the authors
formulated an evaluative design framework that helps architects, urban
planners, and facility managers balance sacred, functional, and social needs:
- Temporal and Spatial Zoning: Core worship zones must prioritize sacred affordances,
restricting photography to designated visiting windows outside of primary prayer
hours.
- Physical and Visual Buffers: Placing subtle, non-intrusive floor elevation changes,
portable low guardrails, or transparent vitrine panels around the mihrab
creates physical boundaries that prevent photo-taking inside primary
prayer spaces while preserving open visual lines.
- Acoustic and Vertical
Separation: Cultural museums, exhibition
halls, and tourist walkways should remain vertically separated from main
prayer halls and equipped with acoustic insulation or raised balustrades
to prevent noise propagation into sacred areas.
- Circulation Fast Lanes: Transition zones should feature distinct floor
materials or wide pathways to separate fast-moving worshippers entering
for prayer from slower tourist crowds.
Academic Insight
Highlighting
the practical value of spatial affordance in modern public architecture, lead
researcher Anggi Dwi Astuti and the team from Universitas Mercu Buana noted:
"The
interior affordances of a mosque are formed through three interrelated
dimensions: sacred, functional, and social affordances. When space
configuration offers competing possibilities for ritual and non-ritual
activities at the same point in space and time, an affordance conflict occurs.
The success of contemporary mosque interior design lies in using functional
affordances—such as spatial zoning, material transitions, and visual
boundaries—to preserve spiritual solemnity while safely accommodating public
community life."
Primary Researcher Profile
- Full Name: Anggi Dwi Astuti, M.Ds.
- Academic Credentials: Master of Design (M.Ds.)
- University Affiliation: Universitas Mercu Buana, Jakarta, Indonesia
- Field of Expertise: Interior Design, Environmental Psychology, Spatial
Affordance, and Contemporary Islamic Architecture
Source Information
- Article Title: Affordance of the Interior Space of Al-Jabbar Grand
Mosque
- Journal Name: Jurnal Multidisplin Madani (MUDIMA)
- Publication Year: 2026
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.55927/mudima.v6i9.122
- Official URL: https://journalmudima.my.id/index.php/mudima

0 Komentar